Proof the Hadith is Not Valid Islamic Law
Call Them What they Are! “Munkiru Al Hadith”
It’s truly heartbreaking, if/when Muslim Afro-Americans still adhere to Muslim-Foreigner Concepts as opposed to simply being Muslim-1st. An Example of what I mean is Muslim Afro-Americans adhering to al-Qur’āniyyah/Qur’ānism. For those who’ve never heard of the Concept before: it basically means that a Muslim only relies upon/uses The Qur’ān as per living via al-Hudā/al-Hidāyah (Guidance).
There’s Several-Problems via al-Qur’āniyyah & I’ll explain:
a. Both The Qur’ān & the
Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition are
at-Tanzīl/Revelation.
b. The Word/Term “Hadīth” means “Documentation/Record”…
…both The Qur’ān & the Sunnah were
documented/recorded via the Lifetime of Muhammad (Peace be upon them).
c. It’s a Religio-Historical Fact, that the Same-Persons whom’re humanly responsible for the Kitābah/Documentation of The Qur’ān are the Same-Persons humanly responsible for the Kitābah of the Sunnah.
The Irony of Qur’ānist-Logic is that we can’t even trust The Qur’ān either. Literally, none of us (relative to the Inception/Invention of Qur’ānism) were there when The Qur’ān was: revealed, written, recorded, documented, reported, etc. So, by default, as per Qur’ānist-Logic: it’s impossible to prove that The Qur’ān is at-Tanzīl/Revelation, the Kalām/Speech of Allah, etc. because the Same-Persons whom documented the Sunnah documented The Qur’ān as well.
19 Hadith Against Sunnah
Ironically, every Hadīth/Athar (Narration/Report) cited/quoted “Qur’ān Talk Blog” is a Hujjah/Indictment against al-Qur’āniyyah/Qur’ānism:
1. Both al-Qur’ān & as-Sunnah are at-Tanzīl/Revelation.
2. The Word/Term “Hadīth” means “Kitābah/Documentation”.
3. Both al-Qur’ān & as-Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition were Hadīth’d/Documented, literally by the Same-Types/Kinds of People.
4. The Fact that you’ve cited/quoted Āthār/Narrations proves that al-Qur’ān & as-Sunnah are inseperable.
5. If you reject as-Sunnah, then how/why are you citing/quoting it in the 1st-Place?!!!
6. How do you know, how can you prove, etc. that what you’ve cited/quoted are Authentic-Āthār of/from Muhammad (Peace be upon them)?!!!
7. Had Those-Ahādīth/Āthār not been recored, then no one would’ve kniwn today that Muhammad had stated anything which you’ve cited/quoted.
8. Qur’ānists are Dummies.
Muslim Afro-Americans whom ascribe to Qur’ānism want to seem/appear “Deep”, but sadly are Shallow as Hell. They attempt to deem themselves “Intellectually-Superior” to those whom’re Non-Qur’ānists. But, the Irony is that everything which Qur’ānism stands for openly defies Basic-Intelligence. Qur’ānism is literally a Muslim-Foreigner Concept, imported from the Arab-World Centuries ago. And it proves undoubtedly that Muslim Afro-Americans have only used al-Islām to switch Slave-Masters, as opposed to utilizing al-Islām as the Best-Tool to correct the Human-Condition. You’ll literally hear Persons pontificate/claim that they “don’t follow Arabs”, yet ironically al-Qur’āniyyah/Qur’ānism (the “Qur’ān-Only” Mythos/Pseudo-Narrative) is in fact totally a Muslim-Arab Inception/Invention.
Muhammad (Peace be upon them) said: “Whomever turns away from my Sunnah/Tradition isn’t from me.”…
…”All of my Ummah/Nation will enter Paradise, except those whom refuse.” It was asked: “Whom will refuse?” They replied: “Whomever obeys me enters Paradise, but whomever disobeys me has refused.”.(al-Bukhārī).
az-Zuhrī said: “The People-Of-Knowledge who came before us used to say: ‘Salvation lies in clinging to the Sunnah.’.”.
(ad-Dārimī).
Malik ibn-Anas said: “The Sunnah is like the Ark-f-Noah. Whomever embarks upon it reaches salvation, but whomever refuses is drowns.”.
(al-Barbahārī)
For More-Infor. regarding al-Qur’āniyyah/Qur’ānism:
www.garethbryant.wordpress.com/2019/11/13/quranism/
Gareth Bryant 1444, A.H./2022, C.E.
Leave a Reply